Divorce Mediation Blog

Why we need a family law arbitration law statute in Massachusetts

Thursday, March 08, 2012

Family law arbitration is a concept whose time is way, way overdue. Arbitration is the private, consensual submission of a dispute to a person whom the parties select and regulate by contract; and that person’s job is almost always to make a final and binding decision for the parties, instead of a judge after a public court trial. The parties pick their decision-maker, accounting for skill, integrity, convenience, cost and subject matter expertise. They choose their place. They set the timing. They define their own rules of procedure – or they may choose to apply traditional courtroom-type rules. They receive their decisions within the time that they direct in their agreement to arbitrate. And, it is all private. So, why isn’t every one doing it?

For one, most people simply do not know that this alternative exists. Its history is mostly in the commercial area of law, and only occasionally have family law attorneys tried arbitration. When they do, they love it. Second, it is not obvious that it makes sense to pay for a decision maker, when taxpayer dollars pay for judges to do that job. At one level this makes sense, but anyone who has spent any significant amount of time in the courts knows that the increased costs of representation by lawyers due to the inevitable inefficiencies of the public system can outweigh the costs of an arbitrator many times, and sometimes many times over.

Third, many lawyers are uncomfortable with the prospect of the process (most have not tried it) because most available arbitrators whom they know well and trust are competing litigators, and selecting a direct business competitor to arbitrate a case when you might be in court against the arbitrator that morning or the next day in another case can be uncomfortable for lawyers and clients alike. Finally, lawyers are leery of the fact that under existing law, all binding arbitration is truly final, and therefore, not subject to appeal, as is a judge-made decision. So, it feels risky to lawyers, as it is the last stop for the client without further litigation recourse.

To address some of the impediments to family law arbitration, several other states have enacting Family Law focused arbitration laws. The American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers (AAML), of which Bill and Chouteau Levine are both longtime fellows, has created a model act (that is, a format that individual states may modify to meet their local needs and practices) for matrimonial arbitration. In turn, the Massachusetts Chapter of AAML has adapted that model act to Massachusetts’ needs, and is in the process of seeking support for its eventual submission to the Massachusetts legislature. Bill Levine of LDRC is leading that effort on behalf of AAML-MA. You can see the Proposed Family Law Arbitration Act here.

What questions or thoughts do you have about Family Law Arbitration?

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


arbitration mediation Divorce private dispute resolution special master divorce litigation pre-ARA alimony COLA self-adjusting alimony Boston SJC Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act resolve disputes family mediation divorce and family law support orders Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly family and probate law disputes Child Support Guidelines health coverage family law arbitrators arbitrator Levine Dispute Resolution Center DOMA Divorce Agreements arbitrators divorce mediators lawyers MLB labor agreement Baseball divorce mediations child support divorce lawyers traditional negotiations how baseball arbitration works divorce mediation alimony orders divorce arbitrators med/arb Chouteau Levine alimony alimony reform legislation lawyer Matrimonial Arbitration Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth The Seven Sins of Alimony Massachusetts med-arb litigation General term alimony divorce and family law mediators health insurance LDRC family law family law mediation Baseball Players Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC Levine Dispute Resolution Major League Baseball Arbitration annulment mediator separation alimony law Baseball Arbitration lawyer-attended mediation conciliation Uniform Arbitration Act family support divorce arbitration dispute resolution Obamacare Alimony Reform Act divorced Self-adjusting alimony orders medical benefits divorce judgment Massachusetts alimony and child support mediations Defense of Marriage Act divorce agreement Massachusetts divorce mediators Same Sex Marriage family law arbitrator fraud Family Law Arbitration facilitated negotiations Massachusetts alimony Levine Dispute Resolutions Massachusetts lawyers divorce mediator divorce process divorce arbitrator high-risk methodology Cohabitation IRC §2704 Massachusetts divorce lawyers disputes mediators rehabilitative alimony alimony statute