Divorce Mediation Blog

When Alimony Meets Federalism

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Recently, Bill Levine of LDRC taught at the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers’ (AAML) 21st Matrimonial Arbitration Institute, a training program for 52 family law specialists from 13 states, in Chicago, Ill. During the program, participants received a fact pattern for a pending divorce case involving property distribution and alimony issues, to be resolved by the student-arbitrators, each in a written “award”, or arbitration decision. The faculty reviewed and critiqued the submissions as the attendees completed their course requirements.

The exercise revealed a fascinating diversity of alimony outcomes. Spousal support, maintenance or alimony (as it is known in different states) is strictly a creature of state law. We in Massachusetts are in the second year of adapting to comprehensive alimony “reform”, just now approaching the first appellate decisions that will shape the 2011 statute (eff. 3/1/12) for years to come. From an outcome perspective, it appears that we fall in the middle of a very broad national range.

Simplified, the fact pattern was: a husband with earnings of $150,000 per year and a wife with a $24,000 annual salary, at the end of a 20-year plus marriage. Both parties were in their mid-40’s. Fairly predictably, in Massachusetts, the Husband would pay alimony of $40-45,000 per year, for 16 years, or for an indefinite durational term. Contrast that with the outer range of outcomes that we saw in Chicago: from $60,000+ per year with no fixed duration to $12,000 annually for a fixed term of five years. We assume, given the nature of this group, that each attendee’s award fairly reflected a sophisticated understanding practice in the writer’s jurisdiction.

We are used to hearing about polarization between “red states” and “blue states” on the gamut of political, economic and social issues in 21st century America, but we don’t hear much about the “alimony gap”. No doubt, this is partly driven by disparate regional costs of living, but there must be more at work here. Federalism produces other stark family law differences such as child support approaches and sums, emancipation ages, mandated or no required participation in college costs and health insurance obligations, but none more dramatic that this apparent spousal support chasm.

One more sign of a Balkanizing America?

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


disputes Levine Dispute Resolution self-adjusting alimony MLB labor agreement mediators support orders lawyers health coverage Divorce COLA IRC §2704 divorce arbitrator family law separation Levine Dispute Resolution Center Boston divorce mediation Defense of Marriage Act Levine Dispute Resolutions lawyer-attended mediation family mediation divorce mediator divorce process divorce litigation divorce arbitration divorce mediators Self-adjusting alimony orders Uniform Arbitration Act dispute resolution divorce and family law Child Support Guidelines Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly Massachusetts divorce mediators med/arb Obamacare divorce and family law mediators The Seven Sins of Alimony medical benefits Chouteau Levine Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC how baseball arbitration works Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act high-risk methodology Massachusetts alimony and child support Massachusetts divorce lawyers facilitated negotiations Family Law Arbitration LDRC traditional negotiations arbitrators alimony law conciliation alimony Baseball Massachusetts alimony Baseball Players Major League Baseball Arbitration rehabilitative alimony family law mediation divorce agreement lawyer Baseball Arbitration Massachusetts lawyers litigation Cohabitation med-arb Same Sex Marriage resolve disputes special master annulment DOMA arbitration health insurance private dispute resolution divorce lawyers Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth arbitrator Massachusetts divorce mediations alimony statute family law arbitrators mediation family support divorce arbitrators SJC mediations Matrimonial Arbitration Alimony Reform Act mediator fraud family law arbitrator alimony reform legislation General term alimony pre-ARA alimony family and probate law disputes divorce judgment child support alimony orders Divorce Agreements divorced