Divorce Mediation Blog

What's In a Retainer? A Cautionary Tale

Wednesday, March 05, 2014

We were recently surprised by a client's statement she thought that a retainer is non-refundable. Our response was easy. The Massachusetts rules that govern the practice of law make clear that non-refundable retainer is an oxymoron. Retainers are advance payments that may be used to fund future services, with any unused portion refunded to the client. Isn't this something that lawyers have known for decades? Maybe not.

Lawyers Weekly recently reported that an attorney represented a criminal defendant and lost big when the client sued for what he alleged was an over charging: $120,000.00 for a case that resulted in a continuance without a finding. While the lawyer tried to characterize his initial $40,000.00 fee as part of the larger "flat fee", the judge whose jury found in favor of the client, re-branded the payment as a non-refundable retainer. The result: a $90,000.00 finding of unreasonable fee, tripled for consumer protection violation, and inflated to nearly a half million dollars, with accrued interest.

What was he thinking? The fundamentals of a retainer are long-known. While this already suspended lawyer may not be a reasonable measure of normal, we have to wonder how many lawyers engage in unethical billing practices because they do not know better? Even worse, are there some who do it purposefully because of the long odds of being caught?

There is nothing wrong with a retainer. If properly explained, it provides client commitment, a certain level of security and cash flow reliability in a field where "what have you done for me lately?" is a common lament. We use small retainers to fund work that occurs outside of our divorce mediation sessions, such as session summaries and agreement drafting. We explain how they work to clients up-front, and no one has yet declined.

The recent case tells us that all we need to be even better at explaining our retainer practices. For firms in which large retainers are the norm, this need is magnified. In divorce and family law, all new clients share some level of vulnerability, and many are prone to re-interpret their relationship with counsel when the need for services abates, especially if the results have been disappointing (as they often are). Ethics and fairness aside, our reputations and ability to earn a living depend on it.

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


Child Support Guidelines Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth traditional negotiations lawyers Same Sex Marriage Alimony Reform Act Levine Dispute Resolution Center rehabilitative alimony The Seven Sins of Alimony Massachusetts alimony arbitrator divorced divorce agreement Massachusetts divorce mediators mediators Massachusetts lawyers Divorce Agreements COLA high-risk methodology divorce and family law mediators family and probate law disputes SJC Cohabitation family law arbitrators dispute resolution divorce and family law Massachusetts alimony and child support Boston Baseball Players divorce mediators Obamacare Uniform Arbitration Act alimony orders Massachusetts divorce lawyers General term alimony family law Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act conciliation child support health insurance Chouteau Levine divorce mediations LDRC arbitration Matrimonial Arbitration health coverage arbitrators disputes mediation annulment Massachusetts litigation divorce mediation divorce judgment resolve disputes divorce arbitrators divorce process medical benefits Baseball Arbitration mediations Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC divorce lawyers Divorce alimony statute facilitated negotiations med-arb fraud pre-ARA alimony IRC §2704 special master private dispute resolution lawyer med/arb Baseball Major League Baseball Arbitration family mediation lawyer-attended mediation Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly how baseball arbitration works Defense of Marriage Act MLB labor agreement family law mediation Levine Dispute Resolutions separation Family Law Arbitration Self-adjusting alimony orders self-adjusting alimony divorce arbitration support orders alimony divorce mediator divorce arbitrator family law arbitrator Levine Dispute Resolution family support divorce litigation alimony law DOMA alimony reform legislation mediator