781.708.4445

wmlevine@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

“Trivial” Disclosures…Where’s the Balance?

Wednesday, November 06, 2013

We received an update this week from a LinkedIn discussion group that highlights a recent California Second Appellate District Court decision to vacate an arbitral award in a legal malpractice case. The defendants discovered, after the fact and after an adverse award, of course, that the arbitrator, a retired Los Angeles Circuit Court judge, who had disclosed his professional work with the defendant law firm, but had not stated that a partner of that firm was listed as a reference on an online resume, many years before (the synopsis called it a “decade old”). The commentator concluded “…the trend seems to be toward disclosure of all matters, however trivial, as well as the imposition of a duty of due diligence in identifying matters to disclose.”

We are challenged by this issue every day as family and divorce mediators and arbitrators. People come to us almost exclusively because they either know us, or know of us by reputation, (shhh, don’t tell our website/SEO experts, who like to feel otherwise) so the potential for disclosures, trivial and otherwise abounds. It is a sensitive matter in mediations, an uber-sensitive in arbitrations. We are surprised how few questions people ask about conflicts and potential conflicts; and we do our best to disclose anything at all that could possibly impact our objectivity – or just as importantly – the appearance of it. But, who’s perfect?

In a long career and with all kinds of significant and passing electronic contacts abounding, among cases, bar programs, educational activities and previous private dispute resolution engagements, the potential for “relationships” of all kinds is too great to quantify. Surely, we are the ones holding ourselves out as available competent and ethical service providers. We do and need to take our disclosures entirely seriously. And, people sometimes think us silly for the disclosures that we do make.

But, shouldn’t this responsibility be shared to some reasonable degree? The internet is equally available to consumers of our services, as it is to us. Anyone, anytime, can Google us, inquire about search results, or simply walk away. But to await an unhappy result, then suddenly discover the web, and complain, seems like a good idea run amok: appeal by ambush, perhaps. Didn’t the plaintiffs in the California case have some due diligence obligations themselves – before the fact?

We will work every day to get this right. But, how about some balance?



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

alimony law rehabilitative alimony medical benefits med/arb private dispute resolution Baseball Child Support Guidelines traditional negotiations divorce process COLA lawyer divorce agreement mediator Massachusetts Family Law Arbitration divorce judgment divorce and family law mediators self-adjusting alimony Massachusetts divorce lawyers Uniform Arbitration Act resolve disputes divorce mediations Chouteau Levine divorce arbitration Cohabitation mediations health insurance family support pre-ARA alimony Baseball Arbitration The Seven Sins of Alimony Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC divorce mediator SJC Self-adjusting alimony orders arbitrator Levine Dispute Resolution Center Levine Dispute Resolutions divorce arbitrator facilitated negotiations health coverage Matrimonial Arbitration DOMA alimony statute Obamacare family law arbitrators alimony orders family law arbitrator divorce lawyers separation alimony Levine Dispute Resolution child support divorced litigation LDRC how baseball arbitration works conciliation special master mediators divorce mediation family law fraud alimony reform legislation mediation family law mediation high-risk methodology Defense of Marriage Act MLB labor agreement Massachusetts alimony Massachusetts divorce mediators arbitration Major League Baseball Arbitration divorce litigation lawyer-attended mediation General term alimony Divorce Agreements Baseball Players family and probate law disputes Boston support orders IRC §2704 Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly Massachusetts lawyers Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act Same Sex Marriage dispute resolution arbitrators disputes divorce mediators med-arb Alimony Reform Act Massachusetts alimony and child support divorce arbitrators Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth divorce and family law annulment family mediation lawyers Divorce