781.708.4445

wmlevine@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

The Voice of the Child: Call me Sam -- I mean, Call Me Nate

Monday, November 25, 2013

Yesterday's (November 24, 2013) New York Times carried word of the Bode Miller - Sara McKenna interstate custody battle that is tabloid fodder in California and New York. Custody of a toddler is at stake in a tug-of-war over jurisdiction and gender rights. Ms. McKenna moved to New York while pregnant; a NYC family court judge refused to grant custody to her after her son's birth, criticizing her for spiriting her fetus from San Diego for forum shopping purposes; the California Court gave Mr. Miller temporary custody, which order he enforced; a New York Appellate Court reversed its lower court; and a new custody hearing is set for Nov. 25th.

In the meanwhile, we have been hearing about and participating in discussions of how the "voice of the child" should be heard and reckoned with in family courts and in mediation. The topic is not without controversy and is far from complete. With a discussion about it in the context of mediation from the Massachusetts Council on Family Mediation Annual Institute, on November 22nd freshly in mind, we were struck by a small but HUGE fact from the Miller-McKenna story that should be the headline of their collective parenting shame:

THEY CAN'T EVEN AGREE ON WHAT TO CALL THEIR SON

She calls him Sam, while he has renamed the boy Nate. Can it get more insane? And, by the way, both parents proclaim their intent to share parenting.

The court cases will come and go. The Courts will make interesting jurisdictional decisions. A woman's right to control her body will compete with a father's right to a fair shake in custody litigation. Lawyers will prosper and courts will compete for jurisdiction. And, in the end, none of it will matter to the subject of this adult madness.

We shake our heads and simultaneously say to one another "This kid hasn't got a chance."



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

DOMA Alimony Reform Act health coverage family law arbitrator rehabilitative alimony divorce mediator Massachusetts divorce lawyers lawyer med/arb Boston alimony reform legislation special master family and probate law disputes Chouteau Levine LDRC Defense of Marriage Act divorced Levine Dispute Resolution Center support orders SJC Divorce Agreements General term alimony med-arb divorce agreement resolve disputes facilitated negotiations divorce arbitration Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act disputes mediators how baseball arbitration works Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC Cohabitation Levine Dispute Resolution Massachusetts divorce mediators Self-adjusting alimony orders divorce arbitrator COLA family law arbitrators arbitrator Divorce Massachusetts lawyers fraud litigation Baseball annulment mediations Massachusetts alimony family mediation Uniform Arbitration Act separation child support Obamacare The Seven Sins of Alimony dispute resolution Matrimonial Arbitration divorce judgment Child Support Guidelines divorce mediations mediator high-risk methodology Massachusetts traditional negotiations divorce lawyers alimony law Major League Baseball Arbitration lawyers alimony Baseball Players mediation self-adjusting alimony lawyer-attended mediation health insurance alimony statute Same Sex Marriage divorce mediation MLB labor agreement divorce arbitrators divorce process divorce and family law mediators family law alimony orders Levine Dispute Resolutions pre-ARA alimony family support medical benefits divorce litigation Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth Family Law Arbitration family law mediation arbitrators private dispute resolution conciliation divorce and family law IRC §2704 arbitration divorce mediators Massachusetts alimony and child support Baseball Arbitration