Divorce Mediation Blog

Some of Our Best friends are Divorce Lawyers

Tuesday, October 08, 2013

There, we said it. Many of them are very good at what they do -- responsible sorts, even; and they are nice people. In a field and among circumstances that tolerate and even encourage some pretty bad behavior, sometimes divorce lawyers are the only cool headed adults in the room. Yet, in a culture that values lawyers only when you need one, we are very free to stereotype and thus condemn a whole walk of professional life with cheap jokes and throwaway lines that if spoken about a race, a gender, a sexuality or an ethnicity, would be taboo. Not so with lawyers -- divorce lawyers foremost.

Such was the case in September 23, 2013's Boston Globe column by Jennifer Graham. In her piece "Free to be you and mean", Ms. Graham explored the case of Lawrence Summer's fall from political grace, shunned from his desired job as head of the Fed, she claims, because he is a nasty man in the workplace. In pressing the theory that the public trust requires competency first and compatibility not-so-much, she reduces divorce lawyers to a cultural cliché, a rhetorical prop. Ms. Graham asks herself "...are there certain jobs where a certain level of jerkiness is an asset?" In mock seriousness we suppose, she answers:

"Divorce lawyers, maybe. I've heard it said that you should never hire one that you like."

We do not say that there are not divorce lawyers who are irritating, difficult, even unlikable. We know a few. Some of them make a pretty good living, too. But, does this make "jerkiness an asset"? In the perverse sense that being difficult to deal with sometimes does make divorce cases longer and more than necessarily complex, and therefore more profitable for the lawyers, can that really be said to be an advantage for the client? Our answer is: "almost never".

Liking your divorce lawyer is no substitute for hiring one who is smart, skilled and measured; but most clients most of the time benefit most from competent counsel with whom they wouldn't mind breaking bread, too. In a relationship that begins with faith and is built on trust, confidence and a sense of pride in being publicly represented by this person, likability matters. It matters in the feelings engendered in the client (often while absorbing unavoidable disappointment), in the opposing spouse, in forensic specialists, in courthouse personnel and -- very much so -- in judges who decide cases.

As divorce mediators and family law arbitrators, we are much aware not only of the competent service that we try to provide, but also the quality of the experience for the lawyers and clients who work with us. In our corner of the business, jerkiness surely does not pay. We know that we see a self-selecting population of clients and counsel -- those who have opted out of the more confrontational or extreme forms of dispute resolution, so we see little of the reprehensible few that Ms. Graham damns with disingenuous praise. But, the cause of one brilliant jerk doesn't justify smearing an entire craft, and it certainly didn't add credibility to the Graham piece.

Now, about journalists...

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


lawyer-attended mediation med-arb Baseball Players child support divorce mediations divorce process Levine Dispute Resolution Center conciliation divorce and family law mediators arbitration divorce mediation rehabilitative alimony Child Support Guidelines family law arbitrators mediation Obamacare Massachusetts COLA family law mediation Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth Family Law Arbitration Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC Levine Dispute Resolution Cohabitation divorce agreement Alimony Reform Act how baseball arbitration works Uniform Arbitration Act divorce arbitrator mediations DOMA divorce arbitration divorce judgment alimony law family law arbitrator separation divorce arbitrators med/arb annulment lawyer LDRC traditional negotiations Boston alimony reform legislation family law special master fraud divorce mediators mediators arbitrator dispute resolution Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly Divorce Agreements SJC lawyers family and probate law disputes divorce and family law Divorce health insurance Same Sex Marriage Baseball Arbitration support orders Massachusetts divorce lawyers divorce litigation Massachusetts alimony and child support Massachusetts lawyers disputes divorced divorce mediator self-adjusting alimony family mediation Massachusetts divorce mediators alimony statute Chouteau Levine family support Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act Defense of Marriage Act alimony orders alimony private dispute resolution Levine Dispute Resolutions resolve disputes Matrimonial Arbitration litigation pre-ARA alimony divorce lawyers General term alimony arbitrators medical benefits health coverage mediator facilitated negotiations Self-adjusting alimony orders IRC §2704 Major League Baseball Arbitration Baseball Massachusetts alimony The Seven Sins of Alimony MLB labor agreement high-risk methodology