Divorce Mediation Blog

Same Sex Marriage Meets Civil Union Dissolution

Wednesday, August 01, 2012

In last week’s Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court’s (SJC) case of Elia-Warnken v. Elia, the court ruled that a civil union from another state (Vermont in the facts of this particular case) is the legal equivalent of marriage when it interacts with our laws of marriage and divorce. The question arose: when a person became part of a civil union in a state that had not yet recognized the right of same sex marriage, and had not obtained a legal dissolution of that union before marrying here, does this constitute polygamy, making the Massachusetts marriage void. The answer was a clear “yes”.

In doing this, the SJC maintained a consistent view that it will not tolerate a continuation of the national practice (that is, in most states individually who do not recognize same sex marriage, and in federal law, where the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) precludes it for federal purposes, and exempts the states from having to acknowledge it) of domestic discrimination against gays and lesbians. The court reasoned that to treat civil unions as anything less than a marriage for our state’s purposes would do exactly that.

So, for a civil union partner to marry in Massachusetts he or she must dissolve one legal relationship before entering into another, whether the prior one be one that is called “marriage”, or a civil union. Strike a blow for marriage equity and against one fear mongered by those who continue to champion DOMA: that somehow same sex marriage will lead a creeping acceptance of polygamous marriage.

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


mediator facilitated negotiations dispute resolution disputes divorce mediators litigation support orders health insurance health coverage annulment family and probate law disputes Levine Dispute Resolution divorce and family law mediators Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly resolve disputes Self-adjusting alimony orders divorce arbitrator family support divorce agreement General term alimony alimony orders alimony Matrimonial Arbitration mediators Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth Massachusetts alimony and child support divorce lawyers lawyer Baseball Arbitration alimony law LDRC med-arb DOMA Levine Dispute Resolutions divorce arbitrators Massachusetts divorce mediators separation Baseball Players Massachusetts family law private dispute resolution med/arb mediation lawyer-attended mediation Obamacare fraud child support Child Support Guidelines divorce mediation COLA family law arbitrator divorce process how baseball arbitration works divorce and family law Divorce Agreements arbitration arbitrators divorce litigation divorce mediator Uniform Arbitration Act mediations high-risk methodology pre-ARA alimony Massachusetts alimony Major League Baseball Arbitration Boston family mediation special master Massachusetts divorce lawyers Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC traditional negotiations Massachusetts lawyers Levine Dispute Resolution Center family law arbitrators alimony reform legislation Family Law Arbitration family law mediation SJC arbitrator rehabilitative alimony Chouteau Levine Alimony Reform Act self-adjusting alimony Divorce divorce arbitration medical benefits The Seven Sins of Alimony Baseball divorce mediations Cohabitation Same Sex Marriage conciliation MLB labor agreement alimony statute Defense of Marriage Act lawyers divorced divorce judgment Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act IRC §2704