Divorce Mediation Blog

“Reconstituted” Majority Nixes Panel Consensus, Again

Wednesday, October 21, 2015

Well, maybe we were wrong about this happening infrequently, and we just woke up to it. Or maybe it is a new trend.

On the heels of Pfannenstiehl, in which a “reconstituted majority” vetoed the 2-judge majority who heard the case, AT v. CR is a new decision in which Justices Meade and Blake’s consensus failed, when other non-panel justices rallied with Justice Hanlon to nullify the panel majority. It is not a family law case, but, rather, a juvenile harassment case.

Again, the majority became dissenters, with Justice Blake (a veteran divorce lawyer and former Probate and Family Court Judge) writing a crisp dissent, joined by Justice Meade. Perhaps coincidentally, Justice Berry, whose minority panel view ultimately prevailed in Pfannenstiehl, voted in the rump majority that carried the day, here.

What’s going on up there at the Appeals Court?

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


Same Sex Marriage alimony statute Uniform Arbitration Act family support family law Cohabitation alimony reform legislation Levine Dispute Resolution family and probate law disputes Levine Dispute Resolution Center arbitration lawyer-attended mediation alimony orders disputes facilitated negotiations divorced DOMA divorce agreement IRC §2704 divorce mediation divorce arbitration Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act pre-ARA alimony Matrimonial Arbitration medical benefits med/arb conciliation divorce process arbitrator COLA med-arb annulment support orders how baseball arbitration works Massachusetts lawyers alimony law separation Massachusetts divorce lawyers family law mediation Chouteau Levine health coverage resolve disputes fraud rehabilitative alimony Divorce Agreements SJC divorce and family law mediators divorce mediations Massachusetts alimony and child support health insurance Baseball Arbitration Boston Alimony Reform Act Obamacare divorce arbitrator Levine Dispute Resolutions mediations dispute resolution Baseball Players private dispute resolution Major League Baseball Arbitration Child Support Guidelines Family Law Arbitration The Seven Sins of Alimony child support special master family law arbitrators LDRC family mediation divorce judgment lawyer divorce lawyers Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth mediator self-adjusting alimony divorce mediator Baseball arbitrators MLB labor agreement mediation Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly alimony divorce and family law Divorce high-risk methodology divorce arbitrators traditional negotiations Massachusetts alimony Massachusetts lawyers mediators family law arbitrator litigation Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC Defense of Marriage Act Massachusetts divorce mediators divorce litigation General term alimony divorce mediators Self-adjusting alimony orders