Divorce Mediation Blog

Recipe for Premarital Agreement Failure, Redux - Allen v. Allen

Wednesday, September 28, 2016

After 2001’s DeMatteo v. DeMatteo, we wondered just what one would have to do, in the real world, to cause a premarital agreement to be struck down as invalid or unenforceable, short of a literal or figurative “gun to the head”, or blanket waivers of everything.

In 2014, we commented here on Kelcourse v. Kelcourse, noting that a husband who sought to enforce a prenup had materially violated the agreement, and generally acted in a matter so unseemly during the marriage itself, that he undermined the very deal that he was seeking to enforce. There was also a vermin factor, but you may go back and read that entry if you are sufficiently curious!

Now, in last month’s Allen v. Allen, a Rule 1:28 decision of the Massachusetts Appeals Court, we have clear primer on how not to conclude a premarital agreement, if you ever want to enforce it. Without further ado, here are the Allen Rules:

  1. Marry someone whose primary language is Portuguese, of which you speak none.
  2. Use hand signals with each other.
  3. Have your non-Portuguese speaking lawyer “explain the agreement” to your intended (assisted by your hand signals).
  4. Arrange for a Portuguese speaking personal injury and real estate lawyer to meet with your fiancée 4 days before the marriage, to orally translate the agreement into Portuguese and give no legal advice (perhaps she didn’t want any; or maybe it was because he had no involvement in divorce practice).
    Make sure that the agreement waives all property and support rights, except to keep the assets that she had before the marriage, disclosed on the agreement as “none”.
  5. Stay married for 15 years and then demand specific enforcement of the agreement which gives her nothing.
  6. Oh, and don’t forget to ask the Appeals Court to bar your wife from presenting oral argument.

Hope you practitioners are taking notes!

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


dispute resolution Baseball divorce arbitrator family mediation divorce judgment private dispute resolution lawyer family law family law arbitrators Massachusetts lawyers mediators divorce litigation child support Major League Baseball Arbitration Boston divorce arbitrators divorce and family law SJC MLB labor agreement med-arb Massachusetts divorce lawyers Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC Massachusetts alimony and child support Self-adjusting alimony orders Chouteau Levine Levine Dispute Resolution Baseball Arbitration divorce mediation mediator separation annulment self-adjusting alimony mediation alimony orders mediations rehabilitative alimony arbitration divorce arbitration alimony reform legislation General term alimony DOMA Defense of Marriage Act LDRC Levine Dispute Resolution Center Family Law Arbitration Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly fraud medical benefits family law mediation alimony law arbitrators divorce mediators Massachusetts divorce mediators Matrimonial Arbitration support orders med/arb lawyers alimony statute divorce mediator Baseball Players high-risk methodology arbitrator IRC §2704 litigation Uniform Arbitration Act Divorce Agreements Alimony Reform Act divorce process family support Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth divorce and family law mediators Obamacare conciliation Massachusetts special master Same Sex Marriage health insurance traditional negotiations The Seven Sins of Alimony Massachusetts alimony pre-ARA alimony health coverage family law arbitrator divorced COLA facilitated negotiations alimony divorce lawyers Divorce Child Support Guidelines family and probate law disputes how baseball arbitration works disputes resolve disputes Levine Dispute Resolutions divorce agreement divorce mediations Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act lawyer-attended mediation Cohabitation