781.708.4445

wmlevine@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

O Pfannenstiehl! Part 2: No Wonder We’re All Confused (The Appeals Court Doesn’t Even Agree With Itself)

Wednesday, October 14, 2015

At least they aren't throwing food at each other, or publicly calling each other names, as the current U.S. Supreme Court is wont to do. In our last blog entry, we discussed the interesting turn in this appeal, from a minority of 1, to a majority of 3 justices, in search of consensus of all Massachusetts Appeals Court, taking this important case away from the judges who heard it, in favor of a majority of the overall bench.

But, the reconstituted majority opinion doesn’t even agree with itself. Here’s why.

Almost casually, the prevailing opinion concluded that:

  1. the husband’s beneficial trust interest is a marital asset;
  2. the husband’s interest is worth 1/11 of the [presumably gross] corpus;
  3. that the wife’s share of the husband’s interest is 60% thereof; and
  4. the husband (in addition to yielding 60% of the non-trust assets) should pay out the wife’s share of his trust interest, in cash, over a 2-year period.

This, despite the fact that the husband is part of a beneficiary class that is open to expansion, and that the trust (no matter how indifferently administered in the past) provides no apparent means by which the husband could compel distributions to pay out the required sums to the wife.

But having concluded and implicitly ruled that the husband could make the required payments…

The court then proceeded to vacate the trial court’s judgment of contempt, in which she found the husband guilty, after he stopped paying the monthly sum to the wife. The reason: that he did not have the ability to pay because the trustees had declined to distribute the funds.
Thus, in the same decision, the Appeals Court ruled that:

  1. The husband as an enforceable right to receive distributions, which gives him the ability to pay out the required sum; and
  2. Because the trustees refused to make distributions that the court concluded he can compel, the wife cannot enforce judgment.

At least, the trial court had the courage of its conviction.

So, what does this opinion do for Mrs. Pfannenstiehl, as a practical matter? We’ll tackle that in our next entry.



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

family law arbitrators alimony family mediation med/arb Boston lawyer IRC §2704 Cohabitation Levine Dispute Resolutions Baseball Players Matrimonial Arbitration family support alimony orders divorce mediators traditional negotiations Same Sex Marriage Self-adjusting alimony orders Baseball Alimony Reform Act medical benefits Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly lawyer-attended mediation General term alimony health insurance high-risk methodology self-adjusting alimony Levine Dispute Resolution Obamacare arbitrator fraud divorce and family law divorce lawyers LDRC alimony reform legislation MLB labor agreement Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC resolve disputes med-arb health coverage divorced litigation divorce judgment Massachusetts divorce mediators mediators pre-ARA alimony mediation divorce mediator disputes Massachusetts lawyers divorce mediation Child Support Guidelines SJC divorce arbitrator divorce mediations divorce arbitrators Baseball Arbitration family and probate law disputes divorce agreement The Seven Sins of Alimony alimony law Massachusetts divorce lawyers mediator DOMA family law Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth COLA arbitration Massachusetts mediations divorce litigation Massachusetts alimony and child support how baseball arbitration works special master Defense of Marriage Act Levine Dispute Resolution Center arbitrators divorce process separation private dispute resolution family law mediation Major League Baseball Arbitration Chouteau Levine Uniform Arbitration Act dispute resolution facilitated negotiations child support conciliation divorce arbitration divorce and family law mediators lawyers annulment Massachusetts alimony Divorce family law arbitrator support orders Divorce Agreements Family Law Arbitration rehabilitative alimony alimony statute