781.708.4445

wmlevine@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

MEDIATION CONFIDENTIALITY: IS IT A STEP FORWARD OR BACK?

Wednesday, October 26, 2016

ZVI Construction Company, LLC v. Franklin Levy & another

The Appeals Court recently enforced the important policy of honoring the right of contractual and statutory confidentiality in mediation, as provided by M.G.L., ch. 233, §23C. The statute states that:

    Any communication made in the course of and relating to the subject matter of any mediation and which is made in the presence of such mediator by any participant, mediator or other person shall be a confidential communication and not subject to disclosure in any judicial or administrative proceeding…

Meaning, that what is said in mediation should stay there, freeing parties of the inhibiting worry that their factual or negotiating concessions may come back to haunt them in court, should their mediation fail to achieve complete resolution.

The plaintiffs in October 6th’s ZVI Construction Company, LLC v. Franklin Levy and another, challenged this important principle by demanding that the court write in a “fraud exception” to confidentiality. The Appeals Court declined, upholding trial court decisions to strike statements made in mediation by counsel from pleadings, and later dismissing all claims based on the defendant’s mediation conduct.

In a case of first impression, the Appeals Court relied on the absence of any fraud exception in the statute and the explicit exclusion of a fraud exception in the Uniform Mediation Act of the Uniform Laws Commission, which is the law in 11 states and the District of Columbia, though not Massachusetts. The court also discussed the celebrated case Facebook, Inc. v. Pacific N.W. Software, Inc., a Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision, in which the federal courts declined to relieve the Winklevoss twins of their mediated settlement by reason of Mark Zuckerberg’s alleged overstatement of Facebook’s value.

Unfortunately, we worry that the Appeals Court diluted its message. In discussing the facts of its case, the court observed that:

    [W]e would be hard pressed to find that such an exception exists in the circumstances of this case, where there is a confidentiality agreement, negotiated between sophisticated people with the assistance of legal counsel… (Footnote omitted.)

We are equally hard pressed to imagine that the Appeals Court intended to imply that a fraud exception might exist in other circumstances.



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

Uniform Arbitration Act divorced divorce lawyers divorce mediators Levine Dispute Resolutions traditional negotiations health coverage disputes alimony reform legislation health insurance resolve disputes divorce arbitrator alimony arbitration Obamacare divorce mediator Divorce General term alimony medical benefits facilitated negotiations divorce and family law mediators Baseball Players Chouteau Levine pre-ARA alimony family support high-risk methodology litigation Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC divorce process The Seven Sins of Alimony SJC conciliation Massachusetts divorce lawyers family and probate law disputes mediations Alimony Reform Act mediator family law lawyer-attended mediation divorce arbitration how baseball arbitration works Boston lawyer Self-adjusting alimony orders child support Family Law Arbitration annulment support orders Child Support Guidelines divorce litigation Massachusetts divorce mediators fraud rehabilitative alimony family law arbitrator divorce and family law private dispute resolution Baseball Arbitration med/arb family mediation separation MLB labor agreement dispute resolution arbitrators divorce arbitrators Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly IRC §2704 divorce mediation Divorce Agreements Levine Dispute Resolution Massachusetts alimony Levine Dispute Resolution Center arbitrator Baseball family law mediation Massachusetts lawyers self-adjusting alimony DOMA Matrimonial Arbitration Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act divorce agreement Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth Massachusetts alimony and child support COLA Cohabitation lawyers divorce mediations Massachusetts divorce judgment mediators alimony statute Defense of Marriage Act LDRC alimony orders med-arb family law arbitrators mediation alimony law Same Sex Marriage special master Major League Baseball Arbitration