781.708.4445

wmlevine@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

Massachusetts Alimony: Watching the Pot - Part 3 An Arbitrator’s Perspective

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

In our last entry, we celebrated the freedom that a facilitative divorce mediator has when the appellate courts have not yet weighed in on the vagaries and pockets of discretion in the Massachusetts’ one-year old alimony “reform” statute. A statute that can be fairly characterized as open to flexible application can promote rather than limit open discussion, which for divorce mediation, is good.

The arbitrator’s view is quite different.

As family law arbitrators, we are essentially, private judges. While classical commercial arbitration law does not confine the neutral to precise application of prevailing law, family law arbitrators are bound to apply the law because the final result must still be deemed to be “fair and reasonable” to the reviewing judge, under our law. Moreover, when domestic relations clients hire an arbitrator, they are looking for objective and reasoned decision-making. Arbitration is not, after all, supposed to be arbitrary.

In this role, we are no less bound than a trial judge in court to search out what the law is on each point, and to apply it to the facts of the case. The imperfect analogies that are the core methodology of legal inquiry, that may hem in mediation, are the arbitrator’s roadmap. Where the parties do not have appellate rights, or even if they did1 , “getting it right” is the goal. Appellate case law is essential to that cause.

Divorce mediators ask: how may the law be applied to best serve this severing or restructuring family? Family law arbitrators (and masters, facts final), by contrast, ask themselves: what would I do if I were a judge in this case? Clear or confusing, slow and steady or sudden and messy, appellate case law gives arbitrators a window into those factors that would influence a judge in exercising discretion and in balancing competing interests that are represented by this complex statute.

For arbitrators, it doesn’t matter what we wish for, rather it simply matters what is. Let the pot begin to boil.


1As would be permitted if the proposed family law arbitration statute that is advanced by the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers – MA Chapter, were law.



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

divorce process SJC Massachusetts alimony Matrimonial Arbitration family law arbitrators Massachusetts alimony and child support Child Support Guidelines family law arbitrator lawyers mediator resolve disputes Levine Dispute Resolution Center mediations DOMA Obamacare divorce and family law high-risk methodology LDRC IRC §2704 alimony orders health insurance Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth Chouteau Levine divorced Baseball Players divorce mediation Boston litigation Levine Dispute Resolutions lawyer mediation family law mediation annulment Massachusetts alimony statute child support COLA alimony lawyer-attended mediation divorce lawyers divorce arbitrators family law arbitrator divorce mediators Massachusetts lawyers Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act Same Sex Marriage arbitrators General term alimony rehabilitative alimony divorce mediator facilitated negotiations MLB labor agreement arbitration separation family mediation conciliation divorce agreement Cohabitation alimony reform legislation Divorce Defense of Marriage Act Major League Baseball Arbitration Divorce Agreements support orders self-adjusting alimony family support traditional negotiations family and probate law disputes pre-ARA alimony Massachusetts divorce lawyers disputes special master Alimony Reform Act med-arb Levine Dispute Resolution The Seven Sins of Alimony divorce arbitration dispute resolution divorce and family law mediators divorce litigation alimony law Baseball Arbitration Uniform Arbitration Act Self-adjusting alimony orders divorce mediations medical benefits Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC med/arb health coverage Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly Baseball Family Law Arbitration mediators divorce arbitrator fraud how baseball arbitration works private dispute resolution Massachusetts divorce mediators divorce judgment