781.708.4445

wmlevine@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

House Bill No. 3091: An Act to Expedite Care and Custody of Minor Children Modification Proceedings

Wednesday, July 05, 2017

Representative Markey of the 9th Bristol District has filed a bill to permit modification of a judgment on child care and custody matters only, without the need to file a new action. It contains provisions for a motion filing fee, preliminary hearing and discovery. The bill provides for evidentiary hearings, but only if requested by a party or set by the court as an exercise of discretion. Temporary orders may enter, mirroring the standards of M.G.L., ch. 208, §28.

We wonder why this bill and why now? It dispenses with the due process requirement of a modification complaint and encourages expedited proceedings, but is that a good idea? Current practice requires a new modification action, but it permits temporary orders and mandates a case management conference at which the court may enter expedient procedural orders that regulate discovery. So, what is new, really?

We presume that the drafters believe that child custody matters require a faster track than other matters involving child support and alimony. But the bill begs two questions: is this really an improvement; and it is good to make custody proceedings a little bit easier to pursue? The answers, in our view are “not really” and “not necessarily.”

There is no doubt that family law proceedings generally take too long and cost too much. But cherry-picking custody cases does not cure these manifest problems, and it may just encourage heedless litigation. Research shows that the most damaging part of post-divorce custody is parental failure to agree on a parenting plan, and continued fighting. Making custody modification even a little bit easier may just encourage more custody modification litigation, which, as a phenomenon, benefits only lawyers.

If permitting judgment modifications by motion, as some states do permit, on the theory that any custody or support matter is technically a continuing matter until terminus, then it should be part of a broader reform of all family law statutes. But, singling out custody matters strikes us as symbolic at best while encouraging litigious parenting.



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

litigation Matrimonial Arbitration disputes Family Law Arbitration Divorce Agreements arbitrators Baseball Arbitration divorce lawyers Alimony Reform Act resolve disputes The Seven Sins of Alimony traditional negotiations facilitated negotiations high-risk methodology General term alimony Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly how baseball arbitration works annulment family law arbitrators child support lawyer-attended mediation alimony reform legislation dispute resolution divorce litigation med/arb arbitrator med-arb MLB labor agreement divorce arbitrators mediators divorce mediators Uniform Arbitration Act divorce mediations Levine Dispute Resolution Center mediator Massachusetts alimony and child support health insurance Child Support Guidelines Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC family law mediation Major League Baseball Arbitration Chouteau Levine family support divorce and family law alimony law family mediation Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth special master pre-ARA alimony health coverage Baseball COLA Massachusetts lawyers DOMA alimony statute Defense of Marriage Act Massachusetts alimony Baseball Players divorce arbitration divorce arbitrator self-adjusting alimony medical benefits mediation divorce mediator alimony IRC §2704 Self-adjusting alimony orders alimony orders LDRC Massachusetts divorce lawyers Same Sex Marriage family law Obamacare Cohabitation divorce process divorce judgment Levine Dispute Resolutions support orders rehabilitative alimony Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act divorced Massachusetts separation mediations fraud Levine Dispute Resolution lawyer Boston divorce agreement divorce mediation private dispute resolution family law arbitrator arbitration lawyers divorce and family law mediators SJC Divorce conciliation Massachusetts divorce mediators family and probate law disputes