781.708.4445

wmlevine@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

Dreaming About Alimony…

Wednesday, February 06, 2019

Levine Dispute Resolution Center - Alimony

In 2017, any waking person knew that Congress and the administration were furiously digging for ways to stem the flood of money out of the U.S. Treasury that they were about to cause by cutting corporate and top individual income tax rates. After all, “elections have consequences.”

In the fourth quarter, it became apparent that Congress had the alimony deduction – a longtime GOP target -- in its crosshairs. As a fiscal matter in context, its cost was marginal, but the decades-old subsidy for divorcing families offended some on moral grounds and compliance was poorly enforced by the IRS, causing greater treasury losses.

But, while the potential yield was small (see our August 15, 2018 post “Alimony and TCJA: Less A Misconception than a Worry…at www.levinedisputeresolution/divorce-mediation-blog/) but the target was rich: middle income and upper middle-class families – many professional – many Democrat – families with large tax rate gaps between spouses, where the alimony deduction helped most. (Low marginal tax rate families gained little from the alimony deduction while both spouses of the uber-rich donor class live at the highest rates, eliminating the value of leveraging family dollars with alimony.)

By December 2017, EVERYONE knew that Congress had repealed the alimony deduction, but had deferred the effective date of repeal by a full year, being effective January 1, 2019.

That’s when Massachusetts’ prominently specialized court, its sophisticated family law bar, financial expert cohort and state legislature all kicked into high gear, to buffer the impact of the family losses engineered by Congress that would soon impact a significant portion of their constituency…

… bar groups immediately conferred on how to press the state legislature to amend the Alimony Reform Act (eff. 3.1.12) in plenty of time to be sure that by January 1, 2019, the courts would have an alimony statute (initially based and passed on presumed deductibility) that is reconciled with the new reality that the federal deduction is gone…

… as they did so, the Probate and Family Court swung into action, setting up “listening” sessions in the various counties so that local practitioners and county bar associations could weigh in on their fears and suggested solutions…

… the court sought out the most prominent experts in the field to begin to come to grips with the economic impact of the lost alimony deduction on its constituent families…

… the court conferred with its judges to see how they might create common approaches to making sure that no one would gain unfair advantage by demanding windfalls for payors or payees, because of an ARA that was now out of sync with federal tax law…

… interest groups communicated to make sure that none of them would advocate for results that would unfairly advantage one side or the other because of the tax law changes…

… the court and various bar groups worked closely to make sure that a legislative fix would be put before the legislature in plenty of time for it to act before January 1st, so that everyone would hit the ground running with the understood goals of the ARA preserved despite federal action...

… the proactivity of the court, the bar and the interest groups led to a unified approach, a smooth glide path to the 2019 reality, so that predictability reigned, and the system didn’t miss a beat…

As I said, I was dreaming…

February 4, 2019’s Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly, Vol. 45, Issue No. 5, article, “Bar: need for alimony fix is urgent” recounts the efforts of the joint alimony task force to move a bill to the legislature with the simplest form of fix, the reticence of at least one interest group, silence from the court -- and as for the legislature – well, who knows. Per Lawyers Weekly, “…the effort is just now gearing up…”, with the horse well outside the barn

As I have asked lawyers in my divorce mediation sessions if they are seeing a common approach in the courts, they look at me like I am still dreaming.



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

divorce litigation divorce mediator mediator family law mediation how baseball arbitration works med/arb Levine Dispute Resolutions family law arbitrator Levine Dispute Resolution Center Divorce Agreements Levine Dispute Resolution MLB labor agreement arbitration SJC Family Law Arbitration Massachusetts alimony annulment alimony law alimony statute divorce and family law mediators divorce mediations divorce arbitrator resolve disputes family support Boston divorce agreement dispute resolution alimony reform legislation pre-ARA alimony Same Sex Marriage Chouteau Levine lawyer-attended mediation Massachusetts alimony and child support divorce arbitrators divorce and family law mediation LDRC Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC divorced The Seven Sins of Alimony alimony Uniform Arbitration Act litigation mediators Massachusetts divorce mediators DOMA high-risk methodology med-arb medical benefits facilitated negotiations family law child support health insurance arbitrator Massachusetts divorce lawyers divorce judgment Baseball Arbitration Defense of Marriage Act self-adjusting alimony support orders divorce lawyers conciliation separation family mediation arbitrators Major League Baseball Arbitration divorce mediation Massachusetts divorce mediators lawyers divorce arbitration health coverage Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth Alimony Reform Act Cohabitation Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act IRC §2704 COLA Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly Divorce special master disputes Matrimonial Arbitration General term alimony alimony orders Massachusetts lawyers lawyer mediations fraud Self-adjusting alimony orders Baseball family and probate law disputes Obamacare divorce process private dispute resolution family law arbitrators traditional negotiations rehabilitative alimony Child Support Guidelines Baseball Players