Divorce Mediation Blog

Arbitration Where Life Imitates Sport: Part 2

Friday, September 14, 2012

In Part 1, we briefly described baseball arbitration and it origins. Now, we discuss how this methodology may apply to family and probate law cases.

In every probate and family financial case, one party is seeking something that the other party also wants, whether it be a specific piece of property or a dollar sum. Sometimes this desire is expressed as a percentage of a probate or marital estate, or income in the case of support.

When parties try cases, they tend to work from the extremities because they anticipate that the judge or arbitrator might “split the difference”, so a party reasons, “why not stretch the range in my direction? If I ask for more than I really want, I may get what I need”. When both parties do the same, settlement chances diminish and the chance of a windfall/stinging loss increase. Baseball arbitration urges both parties towards to middle, so as to cut the risk of the other side’s proposal being deemed the more reasonable.

The applications of baseball arbitration in the probate and family law contexts may include a dispute over a percentage share of the estate. In divorce, a case that is not a clear cut case for 50-50, parties may be more inclined to stay within a more modest range of disparity such as 60-40, to avoid the risk of losing at a more extreme percentage, if the arbitrator concludes that the spouse has over- reached. In business or other property valuation, wild highs and lows are discouraged. The same principles will apply to probate estates.

In a support matters, the support payor may well offer more to avoid the chance of the baseball arbitrator picking the over-the-top request of the payee, but since the same forces are at work, the support recipient is likely to curb his or her demands for the same reason.

The results: the parties are closer together before trial, so the chances of settlement are enhanced; and the arbitrator is more likely to choose a result that is closer to the range with which both parties can live, and reducing the potential for windfalls/calamitous results. But, there are drawbacks, and we will discuss them in our next entry.

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


arbitration fraud Boston special master Divorce divorced divorce arbitration divorce litigation SJC litigation alimony statute divorce process arbitrator lawyers self-adjusting alimony Levine Dispute Resolutions Family Law Arbitration Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly Child Support Guidelines Massachusetts divorce lawyers lawyer-attended mediation divorce mediators COLA Chouteau Levine pre-ARA alimony Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth divorce agreement Massachusetts Major League Baseball Arbitration alimony high-risk methodology separation Obamacare rehabilitative alimony alimony orders med/arb traditional negotiations lawyer Levine Dispute Resolution Center The Seven Sins of Alimony mediators IRC §2704 Cohabitation family mediation family law LDRC Defense of Marriage Act disputes Divorce Agreements divorce and family law Alimony Reform Act divorce lawyers Baseball Arbitration alimony reform legislation Massachusetts alimony arbitrators divorce arbitrators family and probate law disputes General term alimony health insurance divorce arbitrator facilitated negotiations divorce mediations MLB labor agreement divorce mediator health coverage private dispute resolution family law arbitrators child support DOMA conciliation Levine Dispute Resolution Baseball mediator Self-adjusting alimony orders annulment Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act alimony law Uniform Arbitration Act support orders dispute resolution Massachusetts divorce mediators Matrimonial Arbitration divorce mediation med-arb Same Sex Marriage Massachusetts alimony and child support medical benefits how baseball arbitration works Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC resolve disputes mediation Baseball Players family support Massachusetts lawyers divorce judgment divorce and family law mediators family law arbitrator family law mediation mediations