781.708.4445

wmlevine@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

Alimony: Double Dipping In a New Light?

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Massachusetts appellate courts have long struggled with whether a “seeming[ly] unjust” double counting of income occurs when a trial judge divides property that includes a closely held business, values that business using an “income theory”, and then orders alimony to be paid from the same source. The cases boil down to a definite maybe, requiring a court to discern an unfair double dip from an acceptable one, including whether or not there are “separate parts” of the asset. A variety of circumstances could lead the fact-finder to different outcomes.

Now, alimony “reform” legislation (eff. 3/1/12) precludes the Court counting expected capital gains, interest or dividend income from any divided assets, as income for alimony computation. Does this settle the double dip question for all time and purposes? Is the judgmental task of fair or unfair double counting over?

We doubt that the business valuation question was squarely in mind of the legislators when they passed the alimony bill; but it seems inconceivable that the next time an appellate panel hears this issue that the business owner will not argue for a blanket exclusion of any business income for alimony computation purposes, citing the alimony statute. If the argument succeeds, and there is no other source of income to tap for the support of a dependent spouse, where does that leave the parties?

Settlement of one issue always seems to beget another.



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

pre-ARA alimony Obamacare private dispute resolution divorce litigation Massachusetts lawyers Levine Dispute Resolution Center health coverage family mediation Cohabitation divorce arbitrators mediators The Seven Sins of Alimony rehabilitative alimony DOMA child support Child Support Guidelines Massachusetts divorce mediators fraud Divorce Agreements dispute resolution Self-adjusting alimony orders divorced family support family law arbitrators family and probate law disputes Same Sex Marriage MLB labor agreement LDRC litigation General term alimony disputes family law Defense of Marriage Act special master family law arbitrator Chouteau Levine alimony orders divorce mediator divorce process divorce judgment med/arb family law mediation divorce mediations Divorce alimony reform legislation divorce and family law mediators SJC Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly self-adjusting alimony mediation mediations Levine Dispute Resolutions divorce mediators alimony divorce arbitration medical benefits divorce arbitrator alimony statute facilitated negotiations Levine Dispute Resolution Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC Family Law Arbitration arbitration lawyer mediator Baseball Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act Alimony Reform Act traditional negotiations divorce lawyers Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth Baseball Arbitration conciliation Baseball Players lawyers IRC §2704 Uniform Arbitration Act separation divorce mediation lawyer-attended mediation support orders high-risk methodology health insurance alimony law Massachusetts divorce lawyers Matrimonial Arbitration Massachusetts alimony Massachusetts divorce and family law med-arb how baseball arbitration works Major League Baseball Arbitration annulment arbitrator arbitrators Boston resolve disputes Massachusetts alimony and child support COLA divorce agreement