Divorce Mediation Blog

Proposed IRC §2704: Life Imitating Divorce?

Wednesday, October 12, 2016

We receive newsletters from several CPA firms, and they are often both informative and useful. Recently, they are aflame with comment on proposed IRC §2704, issued by the Internal Revenue Service on August 4th. Section 2704 would limit or eliminate the use of discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability for businesses being valued for estate and gift tax purposes: raising values and taxation on intergenerational transfers; and challenging estate planners in crafting tax avoidance/minimization strategies.

To accomplish this, we understand, the proposed rule includes minimum valuation rules (pro rata share of net worth); mandated disregard of ownership agreement and state law restrictions on stock transfers; and close scrutiny of personal goodwill, size and customer concentration concepts as value reducers. Valuation experts and estate planners promise complexity, uncertainty, litigation and general misery ahead. Among other things, critics opine that treating highly illiquid assets, as most small businesses are, as liquid, indulges a fiction that will undermine families’ ability to preserve businesses across generations.

In divorce world, we have seen this movie before. Since 2007’s Bernier v. Bernier, Massachusetts has led the way in severely limiting -- all but abolishing -- the application of discounts in valuation: rejecting the concept that divorce valuation is based on a hypothetical sale, with attendant discounting; and analogizing divorce, instead, to that of the involuntary purging of a shareholder from a going concern for which sale is not, in fact, contemplated. Fair value, rather than fair market value,now holds sway in most cases since business owners can’t dispose of their firms – quite apart from market realities – because they, and their families, depend on the businesses for their economic support. As with proposed §2704, the result of Bernier is higher valuations that often disregard business realities, to the consternation of business owners.

Policy is shaped by goals. In Bernier, the Supreme Judicial Court felt it unfair to reduce the non-owner’s sharing of value when continued operation is the value to the holder, and ruled accordingly. The government wants more tax receipts and the I.R.S., exists to collect it. No surprise there.

Is Bernier the chicken to the federal government’s egg?

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


how baseball arbitration works divorce litigation DOMA COLA alimony orders family support med/arb Same Sex Marriage high-risk methodology child support Massachusetts lawyers facilitated negotiations Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly Chouteau Levine rehabilitative alimony Levine Dispute Resolution Center Massachusetts alimony litigation LDRC divorce arbitrators Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC conciliation General term alimony divorce mediations fraud special master family law mediation Defense of Marriage Act family law Levine Dispute Resolution Cohabitation Divorce divorce and family law IRC §2704 arbitration Major League Baseball Arbitration mediations disputes Uniform Arbitration Act Massachusetts resolve disputes divorce mediator pre-ARA alimony alimony Levine Dispute Resolutions divorce arbitrator Massachusetts alimony and child support arbitrator Obamacare Self-adjusting alimony orders SJC family law arbitrators Massachusetts divorce lawyers alimony law Baseball Arbitration alimony reform legislation Baseball med-arb Massachusetts divorce mediators health insurance The Seven Sins of Alimony traditional negotiations Boston MLB labor agreement family mediation divorce judgment health coverage Baseball Players divorce and family law mediators divorce lawyers Matrimonial Arbitration alimony statute Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act divorce process lawyer-attended mediation divorce agreement lawyer lawyers self-adjusting alimony Child Support Guidelines Twinkies private dispute resolution divorce mediation family and probate law disputes divorce mediators separation medical benefits dispute resolution support orders arbitrators Divorce Agreements annulment mediators Alimony Reform Act Family Law Arbitration family law arbitrator divorced divorce arbitration mediation mediator