781.708.4445

info@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

… Bad Boys, Whatcha Gonna Do? The punishment exceeded the crime for divorce property division in D.R. v. D.A

Wednesday, June 13, 2018

Levine Dispute Resolution - Divorce Property Division

We will not bore you with our complaints about Appellate Rule 1:28 again, but …

In the case of D.R. v. D.A, the Massachusetts Appeals Court found that the Probate Court judge “gave undue weight to the husband’s ‘bad’ conduct such that the grossly unequal asset allocation ‘falls outside the range of reasonable alternatives’”, vacating the 4 to 9 per cent asset allocation to the offending spouse (the parties gave different computations), a difference that the appellate panel deemed “immaterial”.

The bill of particulars against the husband: voluntary unemployment, controlling and abusive behavior, no contribution to household tasks and unexplained negative impact on the habitability of the martial residence. The trial judge concluded that the husband contributed “little to the marital enterprise…economically or otherwise [and negatively impacted] the wife’s wellbeing.”

Elaborating on prior case law in which the Massachusetts courts had established that “conduct” that “harmed the marriage or the marital estate” could lead to diminished recovery under equitable property distribution principles, the Appeals Court resorted to a graphic treatise treatment:

    Negative conduct, to be more than a featherweight factor, must either be economically detrimental to the welfare of the partnership, such as by undermining the family’s economic stability such as through disposal or waste of martial assets, such as through unlawful or fraudulent acts, or be so egregious as to impair the ability of one spouse to function in the future

A pretty specific set of limiting criteria: the kind that a court that intends to assert clarifying precedent would use. The again, D.R. may not be cited as precedent.



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

The Seven Sins of Alimony Baseball Players Matrimonial Arbitration MLB labor agreement Cohabitation divorce litigation Alimony Reform Act Boston divorce mediators facilitated negotiations Massachusetts lawyers self-adjusting alimony SJC support orders divorce arbitrators mediator Family Law Arbitration divorce arbitration family law mediation arbitrator family law arbitrators annulment IRC §2704 Massachusetts alimony and child support Divorce mediators conciliation lawyer-attended mediation alimony law divorce and family law Massachusetts divorce lawyers disputes Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly separation rehabilitative alimony medical benefits litigation family mediation divorce mediator dispute resolution LDRC alimony reform legislation Massachusetts health insurance pre-ARA alimony Levine Dispute Resolution Obamacare Levine Dispute Resolutions mediation family law divorce lawyers divorce process General term alimony alimony statute special master child support Uniform Arbitration Act traditional negotiations resolve disputes Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC Massachusetts divorce mediators divorce mediations lawyers Chouteau Levine how baseball arbitration works divorce mediation Massachusetts alimony alimony Baseball Child Support Guidelines Major League Baseball Arbitration DOMA med/arb divorced med-arb Divorce Agreements divorce arbitrator divorce judgment health coverage Levine Dispute Resolution Center lawyer Baseball Arbitration private dispute resolution Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act Defense of Marriage Act arbitration fraud family and probate law disputes high-risk methodology Same Sex Marriage family support mediations Self-adjusting alimony orders COLA arbitrators alimony orders family law arbitrator divorce and family law mediators divorce agreement Act Reforming Alimony in the Commonwealth