781.708.4445

info@levinedisputeresolution.com

Divorce Mediation Blog

A Prenup Head Shaker from the Appeals Court: Stacy v. Stacy

Wednesday, January 04, 2017

In a Rule 1:28 Memorandum and Order, a panel of the Massachusetts Appeals Court ruled that a pre-marital agreement applied to the death of a spouse, based on contract language that described its scope. Here is that term, fully as reported in the opinion, but broken down by clause:

    … a final and complete settlement of all matters relating to the interest and obligations of each [party] with respect to all future property matters, including but not limited to alimony, support, maintenance, property assignment, and the rights of the parties under G.L., c. 208, §34, as amended, in the event of divorce.

Yet, here is how the Appeals Court must have read it:

    … a final and complete settlement of all matters relating to the interest and obligations of each [party] with respect to all future property matters[.]

    [ ]

    [ ]

The appellate panel tossed out two of the three clauses, which spoke only of divorce, consigned as surplusage, unworthy of consideration, despite the “agreement’s caption referring to G.L., c. 208, §34”, the divorce property division statute.

Now,, let’s cast the provision in the way that is consistent with the maxim that words in a contract are to be accorded meaning within customary everyday usage, with the law of pre-marital agreements that requires that waivers be explicit and the highly probable intent of the parties:

    … a final and complete settlement of all matters relating to the interest and obligations of each [party] with respect to all future property matters, in the event of divorce [,] including but not limited to alimony, support, maintenance, property assignment, and the rights of the parties under G.L., c. 208, §34, as amended[.]

Do you think that the parties’ might have used the word “death” somewhere, if they intended to cover that contingency? Or “estate”? Bequest”? Maybe, “inheritance”? Even “survivor”?

The result is that a widow, with no hint of pending divorce, or even marital strain, must now answer to her sister-in-law (the estate’s personal representative) for “several furnishings and personal belongings” that she removed from her marital home, in part, for alleged violation of a premarital agreement that was to all appearances, extinguished by her husband’s death.

We have no quarrel with the Appeals Court remand on the grounds that a violation of G. L. c. 190B, § 3-709 may have occurred, or that the alleged facts were also sufficient to state claims of a conversion, an unjust enrichment, and a constructive trust. But the Appeals Court is makes unnecessary mischief by inferring intent that doesn’t appear in, or even between the lines of, the contract.



Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:



Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles


recent posts


tags

divorce mediators high-risk methodology MLB labor agreement litigation alimony med-arb family mediation mediation health insurance alimony orders traditional negotiations mediator alimony reform legislation Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC divorce mediation disputes mediators divorce mediator Divorce Massachusetts divorce mediators self-adjusting alimony fraud Baseball Arbitration lawyer-attended mediation family law mediation Levine Dispute Resolution Same Sex Marriage Chouteau Levine Massachusetts lawyers Levine Dispute Resolutions how baseball arbitration works Matrimonial Arbitration IRC §2704 COLA dispute resolution arbitration conciliation divorce arbitration Massachusetts alimony divorce mediations support orders rehabilitative alimony medical benefits General term alimony divorce arbitrators annulment lawyers alimony law Self-adjusting alimony orders separation Alimony Reform Act Child Support Guidelines med/arb Massachusetts Boston Major League Baseball Arbitration family support child support Divorce Agreements divorced family and probate law disputes divorce and family law mediators Defense of Marriage Act health coverage Massachusetts alimony and child support private dispute resolution facilitated negotiations resolve disputes arbitrator special master divorce agreement mediations Levine Dispute Resolution Center arbitrators divorce litigation family law arbitrators Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly pre-ARA alimony family law arbitrator The Seven Sins of Alimony divorce lawyers Obamacare Family Law Arbitration divorce judgment divorce process SJC Baseball Players Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act divorce arbitrator divorce and family law Baseball LDRC alimony statute family law Twinkies Massachusetts divorce lawyers Cohabitation Uniform Arbitration Act lawyer DOMA