Divorce Mediation Blog

2013 Child Support Guidelines Preview Part 2: Which Comes First? The Alimony or The Child Support?

Wednesday, July 17, 2013

In an earlier blog entry, we wondered about how various judges might apply what are arguably competing aspects of the presumptive formulae for alimony and child support. Since 2009, the Child Support Guidelines (CSG) have presumptively absorbed the first $250,000.00 of combined family income, while the Massachusetts alimony “reform” statute (eff. 3/1/12), forbids the use of dollars for alimony analysis, when they have already been exposed to CSG treatment. Since neither specifies which calculation comes first, which is the chicken and which the egg?

This is no idle wondering. Given the opposite tax impacts of alimony (taxable/deductible) and child support (not taxable/not deductible), the economic differences in the two approaches can be substantive, even substantial. We noted earlier that judges addressing lawyers’ groups about their own practices in this regard seemed open minded to hearing both sides of the equation. Meanwhile, as Greater Boston and Western Massachusetts divorce and family law mediators, we have been running the calculations both ways all along, not in an undereducated effort to mirror judicial thinking, but to help inform our clients of the differing possible economic outcomes, in seeking consensus on fair and tax-efficient family support arrangements.

The 2013 CSG resolves the question expressly, if not definitively. They state that neither approach is improper, and that under appropriate circumstances, judges may apply either approach. We applaud this approach as it maximizes flexibility, elevating inquiry and analysis over form, in the search for equity and efficiency.

Get e-mail notifications of new blog posts! Enter email address below.:

Delivered by FeedBurner

other articles

recent posts


dispute resolution IRC §2704 family law arbitrators The Seven Sins of Alimony fraud divorce mediations mediation med-arb Massachusetts alimony lawyer health coverage Massachusetts Alimony Reform Act arbitrators MLB labor agreement Massachusetts divorce lawyers arbitrator alimony reform legislation support orders family mediation med/arb self-adjusting alimony Family Law Arbitration divorce judgment rehabilitative alimony Levine Dispute Resolutions how baseball arbitration works Chouteau Levine Self-adjusting alimony orders Uniform Arbitration Act divorce lawyers divorce arbitrators Boston divorce mediator General term alimony Divorce Child Support Guidelines divorce arbitration family law mediation mediators Baseball Players disputes arbitration resolve disputes litigation Divorce Agreements divorce mediation alimony statute divorce arbitrator separation Major League Baseball Arbitration divorce process special master divorced traditional negotiations Obamacare annulment alimony Twinkies Levine Dispute Resolution Center LLC child support family support lawyers Alimony Reform Act Matrimonial Arbitration Massachusetts lawyers Levine Dispute Resolution Baseball Arbitration divorce mediators Massachusetts alimony and child support high-risk methodology lawyer-attended mediation DOMA alimony orders mediator mediations divorce litigation family law arbitrator family law COLA Levine Dispute Resolution Center private dispute resolution divorce and family law mediators LDRC health insurance family and probate law disputes divorce and family law Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly pre-ARA alimony Massachusetts Cohabitation Baseball divorce agreement medical benefits alimony law Massachusetts divorce mediators Defense of Marriage Act Same Sex Marriage SJC conciliation facilitated negotiations